EveryCircuit
Contact
Reviews
Home
thebugger
modified 8 years ago

Phase Inverters

4
8
297
02:10:56
These are three of the most basic phase splitter topologies. The first one is probably the easiest to grasp. It's sometimes called a split load phase inverter, because the collector load resistor and the emitter load resistor are equal. I personally prefer it, for it's high linearity. It operates at 50% internal negative feedback, so it's considerably linear, before it is overdriven, at which point a very gross distortion appears, where the wave is doubled, as it starts acting as a full wave rectifier. One of the problems with it is that the output impedances of the two outputs are not equal. The output impedance of the collector output is roughly equal to the collector resistor and the output impedance of the emitter output is calculated the same way an emitter follower impedance is. This somewhat makes it hard to balance when loading the two outputs, but careful consideration makes it a perfect phase splitter. The advantages are simplicity and linearity, disadvantages are tendency to gross distortion and sometimes problems to balance the outputs. The second circuit is a differetial pair, which is basically a differential amplifier, with emitter connection. One end works in a common emitter mode, and the second arm works in a common base mode. Perfect symmetry can be obtained when the emitter load is substituted with a constant current source. The advantages of this topology, is that it doesn't need a driving voltage amplification stage, as it has some voltage gain. The other advantage is that when done properly it's very self regulatory and balanced. I've seen many professional circuits use such a topology. From all three presented here, it has the most potential for best balancing. The disadvantages are that it uses 2 active devices to split the phase and is generally much more complicated than a split load inverter topology. The third circuit is a slight variation of the second circuit. The outputs are again taken from the same places at the two collectors, but the second arm still operates at a common emitter mode. To balance the signals, the input signal for the second stage must be taken from the output of the first stage, but first it needs to be attenuated. To do so, you connect the two outputs in a single point through two resistors, so that the opposing currents will cancel out to a given extend. The advantages of this topology is that it gives a very good symmetry, equal output impedances for the loads and it has a voltage gain. The disadvantages are complexity and the requirement for two active devices.
published 9 years ago
hurz
9 years ago
I know from latest topics, your intention seems to build finally a discrete bridge power amp, but the headline is a little Irritating, better is "3 ways to build differential Amplifiers". BTW, there are plenty of opamps on the market with unbeatable performance with differential output. Just mention that, cuz you probably still belive you can do that better in discret form.
thebugger
9 years ago
They're still different types of phase inverters, no matter the construction. And yes there are unrivaled op amps in performance like the LT1115, but you can always duplicate the internal circuit of an IC and get better results. The way I see it, the whole compactness of the components in an IC may have advantages like thermal bonding and relative matching of the parameters, but it also has a few disadvantages, like more strong parasitic effects, that make the integrated version more prone to oscillations and noise, than the discrete version, and the fact that the designers often compromise from performance, because some components are harder to etch on a dye, than others. The other major disadvantage is reliability. That's why most IC's have immense protection circuitry. A failed component means a completely failed IC, and most often the failed component is one of the power transistors, while the driving circuitry is in perfect condition. In a discrete op amp, if you know how to diagnose the problem, it's a simple matter of replacing the failed component, whilst a failed IC may cost you much more. For instance a 2N3055 fails on you. You'll give 1€ and get a new one, replace it, and an IC like LM3886 fails on you. A cheap LM3886 costs 6€ and the original one is around 12€.
hurz
9 years ago
You talking to an bipolar IC designer who worked a few years in this area, and I can only agree a little to your statements.
thebugger
9 years ago
It's just my observations man, sometimes it's necessary to use an IC, sometimes it's not. I tend to avoid them when I can. Bottom line is, the most stable circuits are discrete, they tend to outlast IC circuits by years. I've seen IC's go up in smoke, literally out of nothing. Kept within all parameters and everything and it smoked away, while my father's stereo (a class AA amplifier), has worked for over 30 years now, with little to none failures. I think a power transistor once failed, but I'm not sure.
rich11292000
9 years ago
He is bipolar!!!
thebugger
9 years ago
Yeah that probably means he used to work with BJT's, not that he's bipolar :D
hurz
9 years ago
That less you know about ICs and its differences!
thebugger
9 years ago
Nah, it's probably because sometimes you write a little vaguely. Your previous comment can be interpret in many ways. One of which is that you're insane, which I neglected, the other one which made sense is that you design BJT IC's. I remember you saying that you don't like MOSFETS or something, so I just assumed, that's what you meant. And yes i know the different types of IC's for the most part

EveryCircuit is an easy to use, highly interactive circuit simulator and schematic capture tool. Real-time circuit simulation, interactivity, and dynamic visualization make it a must have application for professionals and academia. EveryCircuit user community has collaboratively created the largest searchable library of circuit designs. EveryCircuit app runs online in popular browsers and on mobile phones and tablets, enabling you to capture design ideas and learn electronics on the go.

Copyright © 2025 by MuseMaze, Inc.     Terms of use     Privacy policy