EveryCircuit
Contact
Reviews
Home
jason9
modified 5 years ago

Light Bulb with Autotransformer

0
8
452
06:05:52
A long time ago I had an idea for a long-lasting incandescent light bulb. You see, the reason the filament breaks is because at such high temperatures the tungsten atoms actually fly off slowly thinning the filament until its so fragile that it breaks. In addition, if one spot is slightly thinner than another, it’ll be hotter and thin more rapidly thereby creating a positive feedback loop that makes one spot get very hot and vaporize while the rest of the filament is still healthy. We can slow this process by making the filament thicker so that more tungsten has to vaporize before the bulb goes out. Now, the length and diameter of the filament are determined by the surface area and the resistance. If we want more surface area (for a higher power, higher voltage lamp) we should increase the diameter and make the filament longer to keep the resistance the same. If we want to increase the resistance (for a higher voltage but same power lamp) we can increase the length and then decrease the diameter to keep the surface area constant. So, if we want a thicker filament of the same power output, we need to decrease the length to keep the surface area (and thus power output) the same but at the cost of lower resistance. This means we need a lower driving voltage. In order to attain this lower driving voltage, we can use an autotransformer. An autotransformer is just an inductor with a center tap (even if said tap isn’t centered but is instead closer to one end than the other). I think autotransformer actually refers to one where the location of the tap is adjustable similar to a potentiometer, but here I’m referring to one with a fixed position center tap. Anyway, it can be modeled by a transformer with two of the terminals connected to each other as shown in this circuit. It basically acts as a step-down transformer, but with one coil instead of two thereby sacrificing the isolating ability of a transformer in favor of simplicity. Since it’s a transformer, it’ll have some inductance which will harm the power factor. As you can see, a capacitor has been included to counter the inductance of the transformer thereby restoring a perfect power factor. The value of the capacitor depends on the inductance of the transformer, but I don’t know anything about what inductance values are/aren’t practical for fitting in a lightbulb so I just stuck with the default 10H. The capacitor might also be bulky and/or expensive since it’s across mains voltage. It could instead be put on the lamp side of the transformer, but at the cost of one tenth the voltage it’ll need have 100 times the capacitance, so it might just be even bulkier and more expensive. Also, as you might have concluded already, such a lamp will no doubt cost more and possibly be bigger than normal lamps. It may also suffer other problems, such as the coil overheating the plastic casing. Furthermore, this isn’t even necessary since normal incandescent lightbulbs could last longer if planned obsolescence wasn’t a thing. In addition to that, this entire idea is terrible because who even still uses inefficient incandescent anyway? Seriously, just use LEDs. As for increasing the lifespan, just buy a bulb that doesn’t bake its LEDs with too much current. Oh, wait, such a lightbulb doesn’t exist in America, or if it does it’s illegal.
published 5 years ago
aaaaa10
5 years ago
Cfl is better but arc lamp can last a lifetime
jason9
5 years ago
I don’t know as much about those two types of lamps, but in reality any lamp can last for a very long time if engineered right. Trouble is, planned obsolescence ensures everything dies quick so that the customers keep coming.
aaaaa10
5 years ago
I would still use incadecent as a heater, emits ir i think
jason9
5 years ago
Yeah, heat lamps are usually incandescent because of the ridiculous amount of IR they emit. In fact, incandescent bulbs convert less than 5% of their power into visible light with the rest being radiated away as IR. Another way to think about why they make great heaters is that they literally heat a chunk of tungsten to white-hot to produce light. I mean, that’s got to be a LOT of heat. I don’t think any other type of lamp uses such high temperatures except maybe an arc lamp, and even for that I’m not sure because I think much of the light might be the electricity exciting the gas. Something like a carbon arc lamp however just makes light via incandescence by heating the soot in the arc between the two carbon electrodes.
aaaaa10
5 years ago
Arc is in form of uv and very hot, mercury heats up and stuff. Think of lighthouses or massive projectiles. Nothing can match lumer per power.
jason9
5 years ago
I know that for mercury lamps it can’t get very hot because it would melt the plastic. The UV is just because mercury emits UV (among other things) when electricity is passed through its vapor. This is because the electricity excites the mercury atoms and when they relax the extra energy is emitted as a photon. However, I’m not sure if fluorescent lamps count as arc lamps because it just makes the gas glow without a proper tight arc like is seen from Tesla coils and such. As for what the line between arc and not-arc is, I’m not sure, so maybe mercury lamps count as arc lamps.
jason9
5 years ago
Also, regarding lumens per watt, nothing beats low-pressure sodium. The only issue is that the CRI (color rendering index) is so bad it’s actually negative, which is interesting. After sodium, the next best is likely low-current LED. The more current sent through an LED, the less efficient it is, so they get really efficient with very low currents. Suitable brightness can be achieved by cramming in a lot of LEDs to make up for the dimness of each individual LED. There may be other more efficient technologies I don’t know of or that are too niche.
aaaaa10
5 years ago
Ha true

EveryCircuit is an easy to use, highly interactive circuit simulator and schematic capture tool. Real-time circuit simulation, interactivity, and dynamic visualization make it a must have application for professionals and academia. EveryCircuit user community has collaboratively created the largest searchable library of circuit designs. EveryCircuit app runs online in popular browsers and on mobile phones and tablets, enabling you to capture design ideas and learn electronics on the go.

Copyright © 2026 by MuseMaze, Inc.     Terms of use     Privacy policy